The UK auto industry is failing in its efforts to reach out to consumers online, according to a new study.

Research by the experience design consultancy Foolproof claims to have identified major shortfalls in the online test drive booking processes of UK car manufacturers.

Discover B2B Marketing That Performs

Combine business intelligence and editorial excellence to reach engaged professionals across 36 leading media platforms.

Find out more

Amongst the worst offenders were Smart, Toyota and Alfa Romeo.

The research evaluated 32 UK car brand websites and found a “concerning picture for the UK car industry”, with only a small number of manufacturers’ online booking processes offering customers a viable, useful experience.

It went on to say that, in general, the processes were characterised by: poor visibility and promotion on the site; poor usability; requests for irrelevant personal information and poor channel integration.

A small number of manufacturers emerge with some credit from the study although, in all cases, Foolproof said there was significant room for improvement, with even the best sites falling short against a number of key benchmark principles.

The report claims that only a quarter of manufacturers allow customers to choose when a test drive will take place. Of those, only 38% provide time slots of two hours or less.

“Half day slots are not specific enough for customers to plan their day. Websites should aim to show which time slots are available and which are already taken. This type of live time booking is common-place on supermarket home delivery websites and, nowadays, consumers demand this level of flexibility as standard,” the report said.

Tom Wood, managing partner of Foolproof said: “Given the importance of the test drive within the new car sales journey, our review of online booking systems raises some worrying questions. It’s likely that every year these systems push many thousands of frustrated potential customers back into traditional channels for booking. By doing so, they threaten immediate sales as well as creating a long-term drag on customer satisfaction and brand loyalty.

“The study looked at just one aspect of the digital customer experience. But it was enough to convince us that there is potential for significant competitive advantage for motor brands that engineer an improved user experience.”

The best scoring sites were Volkswagen, Honda and Renault. “These sites successfully adopted some of the best practice user experience standards for booking systems from other industries. They also appear to have put more effort into aligning the online and offline channels,” Foolproof said.

The full report can be found by clicking here.

Just Auto Excellence Awards - Nominations Closed

Nominations are now closed for the Just Auto Technology Excellence Awards. A big thanks to all the organisations that entered – your response has been outstanding, showcasing exceptional innovation, leadership, and impact.

Excellence in Action
Continental has secured the Window Displays Innovation Award in the 2025 Just Auto Excellence Awards for its Window Projection solution, transforming side windows into dynamic, data-rich canvases. Discover how this compact projection technology and intelligent software are reshaping in-car UX and opening fresh revenue streams for OEMs and mobility providers.

Discover the Impact